In this week’s guest post, Liz Scott returns to discuss a framework she utilises in her coaching.
What the Belbin!
By Liz Scott
My husband is a plant. Now that I know it makes it easier to communicate. I don’t mean that he’d look good in a herbaceous border and I don’t mean he’s some heavy duty machinery – no my husband is a plant of the ideas kind.
For those of you familiar with Belbin (a psychometric testing technique to determine team roles) then you’ve probably heard of some of the names of the 9 different team roles. Names like ‘plant,’ ‘shaper,’ or ‘specialist’ are to name a few. I discovered that I was a strong ‘implementer.’ In the world of Belbin this means I’m great at organising, scheduling and getting things done.
When we both went on the course to become Belbin facilitators we had no idea that our marriage would also benefit as we began to understand how and why we interact and behave in the way we do.
For example when we have a dinner party – I’ll write lists, write timings of what goes in which oven and generally plan how to get the house ready (typical traits of an ‘implementer’). Once this is done I feel I can switch off as it’s all under control. My husband by contrast will wake up in the morning and say something like, “I think I’ll make a Pavlova tonight,” (plants typically come up with spontaneous ideas) and he’ll nip out get the ingredients and whip up a meringue completely ignoring all the other things that have to be done that day.
Now when we have a dinner party I fully expect my husband to have some great last minute ideas and I’m quite relaxed about it. He might not be as great at organising and planning as I am– but he does have some great ideas… and his Pavlova’s are delicious!
Since Belbin we’re much more able to laugh at our differences rather than make an issue out of them. Indeed Belbin is very much about playing team members to their strengths rather than trying to get them to improve their weaknesses. If you’ve got a great goal keeper then you don’t need to play them as a striker to improve their goal-scoring skills. Keep in them in goal and appreciate what they bring to the team.
Indeed as a result of this Belbin training we’ve not only really begun to appreciate each others’ strengths but also those of people around us. This is an excellent philosophy to adapt to life. What would it be like if instead of focussing on someone’s weakness that we instead fully appreciated their strengths? And taking it a step further, what would it be like if instead of focussing on your own ‘faults’ you became clear on your own strengths?
As a coach it can be really helpful to utilise a framework like “Belbin” to help explain strengths and weaknesses to a client. When you work with a client using Belbin it can ensure the conversation is very non-threatening about potential vulnerabilities. It can also help clients to really understand and appreciate the strengths of others too.
About the Author/Further Resources
Liz Scott is the co-founder of Coaching Connect. Coaching Connect brings coaches together to share experience and expertise both on the web and at popular coaching events. Meet like minded coaches at the next Coaching Connect events Develop your Talents with Johnny Tenn and Coaching Connect Autumn
To read Liz’s previous guest post “Listening” click here.
Hi Liz – thanks for the post.
I totally agree with how much the coaching work I do in a business sense has applications for all the other relationships in my life (most importantly, of course, with my beautiful wife).
I had a question about Belbin and 9 roles – do your clients find those easy to remember? It just seems like a lot, and the names (based on what you’ve shared here) don’t seem intuitive – I would have thought a plant rarely had ideas, let alone spontaneous and fabulous ones like Pavlova.
The indicator system I use is ThinkFeelKnow (http://www.navitasip.com/indicators/ThinkFeelKnow.aspx). I like the simplicity – 3 areas, and we all have part of each one so there’s no us-and-them, plus they are clearly named (eg, a Thinker is up in their head). I’ve compared it to Myers-Briggs and DISC, which have 4 categories and seem more complex as a result, hence my question about a team member needing to remember what all 9 mean.
Liz,
A very good and thought provoking post. I think awareness of the different roles within a team is very important. Another key aspect of this is how team dynamics change when a member leaves a team and a new person joins. Using the BELBIN anlologies if a plant leaves the team and is replaced by an implementer this can have a significant impact on team performance. In sport it would be akin to replacing a fleet footed full back with a twenty stone prop forward.